Photo of Manhattan NY Pizza

Manhattan NY Pizza

A New York-style pizzeria in Harbor Shops on Cordova Road with whole pies, pasta and subs, a pizza party deal for groups, beer and wine, and hours until 2 a.m.

Pizza RestaurantItalian Restaurant$$· Family Friendly· Good for Groups· Late Night· Neighborhood Gem
Manhattan NY Pizza is a pizzeria at 1923 Cordova Rd in the Harbor Shops plaza. The site says the dough is made in New York, the pizza is made in Fort Lauderdale, and pies have been made at this location since 2018. A 2022 blog post called it small and crowded with a cramped order counter and liked the El Fuego pie's foldable crust and the garlic knots. The official menu lists the Manhattan Classic at $15.95, specialty pies at $22.95 to $24.95, gluten-free pies at $18.95, pasta and entrees at $14.95 to $19.95, sandwiches at $12.95 to $16.95, wings at $9.95, garlic knots at $6.95 and cannoli at $6.50. A Pizza Party deal covers five large pies for 20 people at $75.95, there is a kids pasta menu, and the menu lists draft beer, bottled beer and wine. The site lists hours of 10 a.m. to 2 a.m. every day with dine-in, pickup and delivery within four miles. One aggregator also describes game screens, but that is not on the official site. Google reviewers rate it 4.4 across about 1,300 reviews. Menu items, prices, and hours may have changed since this was written.